Uninformed Castrato Program The only television program about castrati that I recall having seen was a poorly conceived and produced one from Britain. (I actually have a DVD copy of it somewhere but never look at it.) It almost seemed to me that the producer(s) had a fascination with the topic but no real knowledge either about castrati or singing voices in general. They mentioned only a small percentage of the information that they could have covered.
Worse, they attempted to demonstrate the differences between the sounds of boy sopranos vs. female sopranos vs. falsetto sopranists vs. male sopranos. To accomplish a valid comparison, they should have chosen top-quality singers who also possessed voices similar to that of castrati as as accurately described in written works and medical texts. Instead, the boy soprano was not even of average quality. The female soprano's voice was distinctly feminine with heavy vibrato, the man who fancied himself to be a sopranist was so terrible that he never should have opened his mouth (any man or boy off the street could have produced similar noise), and lastly, they chose natural male soprano Michael Maniaci who does sing soprano but who has a very feminine voice with heavy vibrato. Perhaps the selection was meant to "stack the deck" in favor of Micheal, but it was worthless for comparisons.
There may be other castrati documentaries available, not always in English; however, I have no information about any. |